Common Hot Water Cylinder Problems and How to Fix Them
Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire & Cambridgeshire
The most common hot water cylinder problems are no hot water, lukewarm water, water dripping from the tundish or discharge pipe, leaks, noisy heating and low pressure, and most come down to a failed immersion heater or thermostat, a stuck motorised valve, limescale or, on unvented cylinders, a lost air gap or expansion vessel charge. Some checks are safe to do yourself, but anything involving the safety valves on an unvented cylinder needs a qualified installer.
In short
- First work out whether you have a vented cylinder (tank in the loft) or an unvented cylinder (mains pressure, with safety valves and a tundish).
- No hot water is usually the programmer, cylinder thermostat, motorised valve, immersion heater or the boiler.
- Water from the tundish on an unvented cylinder often means a lost air gap or expansion vessel charge, and should never be ignored.
- Lukewarm water and noisy heating are often caused by limescale, which is common in Hertfordshire’s hard water.
- Unvented cylinders should be serviced every year by a qualified installer.

Vented or unvented: which do you have?
The fix depends on the type of cylinder, so start here.
| Vented cylinder | Unvented cylinder | |
|---|---|---|
| How it is fed | From a cold water tank in the loft, by gravity | Directly from the mains, at mains pressure |
| What it looks like | Often copper, with a vent pipe going up to the loft | Usually a white or coloured insulated case, with valves, often an expansion vessel and a small open funnel (tundish) on a pipe |
| Water pressure | Depends on the height of the loft tank | Mains pressure at hot taps and showers |
| Safety devices | Open vent pipe | Pressure reducing valve, expansion relief valve, temperature and pressure relief valve, thermal cut-outs |
| Who can work on it | A competent plumber | A qualified unvented installer, as required by Building Regulations |
If you have an unvented cylinder and you are not sure when it was last serviced, book one before problems start. Our unvented cylinder page explains what we check.
1. No hot water
This is the most common call. The cylinder does not heat the water itself; the boiler or an immersion heater does, so the fault can be in several places.
Check these first
- Is the hot water programmer or smart thermostat set to “on” for hot water, and is the time correct?
- Is the cylinder thermostat (a dial on the side of the cylinder) turned right down? It is usually set to around 60°C.
- Is the boiler working and firing for heating? If the heating is also off, the problem is probably the boiler.
- If you have an immersion heater, is its switch on and has the fuse or circuit breaker tripped?
Common causes
- A motorised valve that has stuck or whose motor has failed, so the hot water from the boiler never reaches the cylinder coil.
- A faulty cylinder thermostat.
- A failed immersion heater element, often from limescale building up on it.
- A boiler fault.
If the heating works but the hot water does not, our guide to no hot water but the heating works goes through the checks in order.
2. Water dripping from the tundish or discharge pipe
On an unvented cylinder, the tundish is a small open funnel on the pipework, and the discharge pipe carries water from the safety valves safely outside. Water appearing there means one of the valves is releasing pressure.
| What you see | Likely cause |
|---|---|
| Drips when the water is heating up, stopping when it is hot | Lost air gap or expansion vessel charge, so there is nowhere for the expanding water to go |
| A constant drip, even when not heating | Worn expansion relief valve or a failing pressure reducing valve |
| Very hot water or steam discharging | The water is overheating; the temperature and pressure relief valve is doing its job |
Some cylinders have an internal air gap instead of an external expansion vessel. Baxi’s guidance for its Megaflo cylinders says that water dripping from the safety pipe or through the tundish is a sign the air gap needs recharging, that homeowners can follow the instructions on the label on the cylinder, and that if the dripping continues you should contact a G3 qualified installer.
If hot water or steam is coming from the tundish
- Switch off the immersion heater and turn off the boiler or the hot water setting, so the cylinder stops heating.
- Do not touch the discharge pipe; it may be very hot.
- Do not adjust, cap or block the safety valves or the discharge pipe. They are there to stop the cylinder failing dangerously.
- Call a qualified unvented cylinder engineer.
3. Lukewarm or not hot enough
- Thermostat set too low on the cylinder, or a thermostat that has failed.
- Limescale coating the coil or the immersion element, which insulates it and slows heating. Most of Hertfordshire has hard water, so this is common.
- Sludge in the heating system reducing flow through the coil.
- The boiler’s hot water temperature set too low on a system or regular boiler.
- Hot water programme too short to heat the whole cylinder.
The HSE advises that stored hot water should be kept at 60°C or above to control legionella, and that it should reach at least 50°C at the tap within a minute. Turning the cylinder thermostat right down to save energy can undermine that.
4. The cylinder is leaking
Look carefully to find where the water is coming from before assuming the cylinder has failed.
| Where | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| From a joint or valve | Loose or corroded fitting, worn washer | Remake or replace the fitting |
| From the immersion heater boss | Failed seal or corrosion | New seal or immersion heater |
| From the body of a copper cylinder | Corrosion, often at the base | Replace the cylinder |
| From the discharge pipe | A safety valve releasing (see above) | Engineer diagnosis |
A small weep from a copper cylinder rarely gets better. If the body of the cylinder is leaking, it needs replacing, and that is often a good time to consider whether an unvented cylinder would suit you better.
5. Noisy cylinder or pipes
Rumbling, kettling or banging when the water heats up is usually limescale on the immersion element or coil, or a thermostat that lets the water get too hot. Banging when taps close is more often water hammer in the pipework. Our guide to banging pipes and water hammer covers that.
6. Low hot water pressure
On a vented cylinder, pressure depends on how high the loft tank is above the tap, so low pressure upstairs is normal. On an unvented cylinder, low pressure is more likely to be a blocked strainer, a faulty pressure reducing valve or a problem with the mains supply. If the cold is weak too, see our guide to low water pressure in the whole house.
7. Discoloured or smelly water
Brown or rusty water from the hot taps on a vented system can come from corrosion in an old loft tank or the cylinder. Unusual smells, especially from a cylinder that has not been used for a while, should be looked at promptly. Run the taps, keep the stored temperature at the level the HSE recommends, and get an engineer to inspect the cylinder and tank.
What you can and cannot do yourself
You can safely:
- check the programmer, cylinder thermostat and immersion switch,
- reset a tripped circuit breaker once,
- recharge the air gap on a cylinder if the manufacturer’s label and user guide say homeowners can,
- look for leaks and put a container under a drip.
Leave to a qualified engineer:
- anything involving the safety valves, expansion vessel or discharge pipe on an unvented cylinder,
- replacing an immersion heater or thermostat,
- motorised valve repairs,
- any work on the boiler, which needs a Gas Safe registered engineer.
Keeping a cylinder healthy
- Service unvented cylinders every year. The safety valves, expansion vessel charge and pressure reducing valve all need checking. Manufacturer guarantees usually depend on it.
- Deal with hard water. A water softener or scale protection reduces limescale on coils and elements.
- Keep the stored water at 60°C.
- Keep the system water clean with a magnetic filter and inhibitor, which also protects the cylinder coil.
What it costs with Vantage
In normal working hours there is no call-out fee. After the first hour, time is charged in half-hour steps, and parts are quoted before we fit them. Evening, weekend and overnight visits are charged at the out-of-hours rates. Every rate is published on our prices page, so you know what you will pay before we arrive. If you need a new cylinder, installations are quoted as a fixed price after a free survey. Our work carries a 12 month labour guarantee.
Frequently asked questions
Why is water coming out of my tundish?
On an unvented cylinder, water in the tundish means a safety valve is releasing. The most common reasons are a lost air gap or expansion vessel charge, a worn relief valve or a failing pressure reducing valve. If the water is very hot or there is steam, switch off the heating to the cylinder and call an engineer straight away.
How long does a hot water cylinder last?
It depends on the type, the water quality and maintenance. Copper vented cylinders often last many years but eventually corrode, while unvented cylinders last longest when they are serviced every year. Hard water shortens the life of immersion heaters and coils.
Why has my immersion heater stopped working?
The most common reasons are a burnt-out element, a failed thermostat or a tripped fuse or circuit breaker. In hard water areas, limescale on the element makes it run hotter and fail sooner. Replacing an immersion heater involves draining down and electrical work, so it is a job for an engineer.
Do unvented cylinders need servicing?
Yes. Manufacturers recommend an annual service by a qualified installer to check the safety valves, the expansion vessel or air gap, and the pressure reducing valve. Skipping it can affect the guarantee and lets small faults turn into leaks.
Is a leaking hot water cylinder an emergency?
A small drip from a fitting can usually wait for a booked visit if you catch the water in a container. A steady leak, water near electrics or hot water discharging from the tundish is urgent. Turn off the heating to the cylinder, turn off the water at the stopcock if needed and call for help.
Cylinder repairs in Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and Cambridgeshire
If your cylinder is leaking, dripping from the tundish or not heating, we can diagnose and repair it. See our unvented cylinder page or, for an urgent leak, our emergency plumbing service, or call 01462 506374, answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
What our customers say
Speak to a local engineer
Vantage Plumbing and Heating covers Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and the surrounding areas. Call and talk to an engineer, or send us the details and we will come back to you with a price.
Gas Safe registered, number 956889. Emergency line answered 24/7.
Boiler engineers near you
Boiler playing up? Book a local Gas Safe engineer
We cover Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and Cambridgeshire. Choose your town:
Not listed? See all the areas we cover or call 01462 506 374