Sump Pump Problems: Signs of Failure and What to Do
Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire & Cambridgeshire
A sump pump usually fails for one of five reasons: the power has gone off, the float switch has stuck, the pump or its inlet is clogged with silt or debris, the non-return valve has failed so water runs back in, or the discharge pipe outside is blocked or frozen. If the high-level alarm is sounding or water is rising in the sump, check the power and the outside discharge point first, stop using any drains that feed a sewage pump, and get an engineer out quickly, because a basement or cellar can flood in hours.
In short
- Warning signs: the alarm sounding, the pump running non-stop, switching on and off rapidly, not starting, unusual noise, or water rising in the chamber.
- Check the power, the RCD and the outside discharge point first. These are safe and fix a surprising number of failures.
- A stuck float switch and a failed non-return valve are the most common mechanical faults.
- Well designed systems have two pumps, a high-level alarm and a way to keep pumping in a power cut.
- Pumps need regular servicing. A pump that is never checked tends to fail when it is needed most.

What a sump pump does
A sump pump sits in a chamber, the sump, at the lowest point of a basement, cellar or below-ground room, and pumps out water that collects there. In UK homes you will usually find one of two kinds.
- Groundwater sump pumps. Part of a basement waterproofing system, often a cavity drain membrane. Water that gets through the walls or floor is guided into channels and down to the sump, and the pump sends it out to a drain or soakaway.
- Sewage or foul water pumping stations. Where a basement toilet, shower or utility room is below the level of the drain, waste runs into a sealed chamber and a pump lifts it up to the sewer. Approved Document H says a foul pumping installation should be sized to hold 24 hours of inflow, so there is time to deal with a failure.
In both cases a float switch senses the rising water level and starts the pump, and a non-return valve on the outlet stops pumped water running back in. Well designed systems have a primary and secondary pump and a high-level alarm that warns you if the water rises too far. Our drainage services team deals with the drains and discharge pipework these pumps depend on.
Signs your sump pump is failing
- The high-level alarm is sounding. The water has risen above where the pump should have started. Treat this as urgent.
- The pump runs constantly. Either water is coming in faster than it can pump, the float is stuck in the on position, or water is running back in through a failed non-return valve.
- It switches on and off every few seconds. This short cycling is often a non-return valve problem or a float set too close to the pump.
- It does not start at all. No power, a stuck float, a seized motor or a failed switch.
- It hums but no water moves. The impeller or inlet is blocked, or the motor is failing.
- Grinding, rattling or loud vibration. Debris in the impeller or worn bearings.
- Damp, puddles or a smell in the basement. Water is getting past the system, or a sewage chamber is leaking or not sealed.
Check these first
These checks are safe for a homeowner and do not involve touching the pump or putting your hands in the water.
- Check the power. Is the pump’s socket or spur switched on? Has a breaker or RCD tripped on the consumer unit? If an RCD trips again immediately, leave it off and call an engineer, because a pump fault in water is an electrical hazard.
- Check the alarm. If the alarm has a battery, make sure it is working. Note whether it is showing a high water level or a fault.
- Look at the outside discharge point. Find where the pump’s outlet pipe discharges, often into a gully, drain or soakaway. Clear leaves or debris from a gully grating, and in freezing weather check the pipe end is not blocked with ice.
- Look into the sump without touching. With the lid off, is the water high? Is the float visibly jammed against the side of the chamber or tangled with a cable?
- For a sewage pump, stop using the fittings that feed it. Do not flush the basement toilet or run the shower or washing machine until it is working again.
- Test a groundwater pump if it looks normal. On a groundwater system, the installer’s guide may suggest pouring a bucket of clean water into the sump to check the pump starts and stops. Do not do this on a foul water pump.
Safety first
- Water and electricity are a dangerous mix. Never put your hands into a sump while the pump has power.
- Sewage chambers contain foul water and can hold harmful gases. Do not climb into or lean into a sewage chamber.
- Do not try to take the pump apart or change the float settings yourself.
- If water is entering living areas near sockets or appliances, switch off the power to that area at the consumer unit if it is safe to reach.
Common causes of sump pump failure
| Cause | What you might notice | Can you fix it yourself? | What the engineer does |
|---|---|---|---|
| Power cut or tripped RCD | Pump silent, alarm may sound | Reset once, if it holds | Finds why it tripped, checks the pump’s electrics |
| Float switch stuck or tangled | Pump never starts, or never stops | No | Frees or replaces the float and sets the switching levels |
| Clogged inlet or impeller | Hums but does not pump, or pumps slowly | No | Lifts the pump, clears silt and debris, checks the impeller |
| Failed non-return valve | Short cycling, water heard running back | No | Replaces the valve |
| Blocked or frozen discharge pipe | Pump runs but water level does not drop | Clear an outside gully only | Clears the pipe and the drain it discharges into |
| Pump too small for the inflow | Runs constantly in wet weather, alarm in storms | No | Checks inflow and advises on pump capacity or a second pump |
| Worn-out pump | Noisy, slow, overheating, frequent trips | No | Replaces the pump |
| No backup | Flooding in a power cut or when one pump fails | No | Advises on a second pump, battery backup and an alarm |
Blocked drains beyond the pump
A pump can only work if the drain it discharges into is clear. If the pump is running but the water level barely drops, and the outlet pipe is clear, the problem may be in the drain or gully it empties into. Our drain blockage team can clear it, and a CCTV drain survey shows whether the pipe is damaged.
Preventing sump pump failure
- Have the system serviced regularly. Follow the installer’s or manufacturer’s service interval, and do not let a system that protects living space go more than a year unchecked. A service checks the pumps, floats, valves and alarm, and clears silt from the chamber.
- Check the alarm and replace its battery when needed.
- Keep the outside discharge point clear of leaves and debris, especially in autumn.
- Protect against power cuts. A battery backup or a second pump on a separate supply keeps pumping when the main pump cannot.
- Keep the paperwork. Many basement waterproofing guarantees depend on the pumps being serviced. Check yours before anyone else works on a system still under guarantee.
- For sewage pumps, only flush toilet paper. Wipes and sanitary products are a common cause of blockages in foul pumps.
Repair or replace?
Floats, non-return valves and alarms are straightforward parts to replace. A pump that is noisy, overheating or tripping the power, or one that has had a long, hard life, is often better replaced than repaired. If your system has only one pump and no backup, the time to fix that is before the next storm, not during it.
What it costs with Vantage
In normal working hours there is no call-out fee. After the first hour, time is charged in half-hour steps, and parts are quoted before we fit them. Evening, weekend and overnight visits are charged at the out-of-hours rates. Every rate is published on our prices page, so you know what you will pay before we arrive.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my sump pump running constantly?
Either water is coming in faster than usual, such as in prolonged heavy rain, or something is wrong: a float stuck in the on position, a failed non-return valve letting water run back, or a blocked discharge pipe. If the water level is not dropping while the pump runs, get it checked quickly.
What happens if a sump pump fails?
The water level in the chamber rises, and if nothing is done it overflows into the basement or cellar. With a foul water pump, that means sewage. A high-level alarm and a second pump are there to give you warning and time.
How long does a sump pump last?
It depends on how often it runs, what it pumps and how well it is maintained. Pumps that run often, or pump silty water, wear out sooner. Regular servicing is the best way to catch a pump that is nearing the end of its life.
Can I reset my sump pump?
You can reset a tripped breaker or RCD once, and some alarms have a reset or mute button. If the power trips again, or the pump still does not start, leave it for an engineer rather than resetting it repeatedly.
Who is responsible for a pumped drain?
A pump inside your property, serving only your home, is normally your responsibility. The drain it discharges into may be shared or public beyond your boundary. Our guide on who is responsible for clearing a blocked drain explains where the lines usually fall.
Help in Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and Cambridgeshire
If your sump pump alarm is sounding or water is rising, check the power and the outside outlet, stop using any drains that feed a sewage pump, and call us. Our engineers can check the pump, clear the discharge pipe and the drains it feeds, and advise on what needs replacing. See our drainage services or our emergency drainage page, or call 01462 506374, answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
What our customers say
Speak to a local engineer
Vantage Plumbing and Heating covers Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and the surrounding areas. Call and talk to an engineer, or send us the details and we will come back to you with a price.
Gas Safe registered, number 956889. Emergency line answered 24/7.
Plumbers near you
Need a plumber? Our own engineers cover the area, 24/7
We cover Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and Cambridgeshire. Choose your town:
Not listed? See all the areas we cover or call 01462 506 374