Underfloor Heating Pros and Cons: An Honest Guide
Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire & Cambridgeshire
The main advantages of underfloor heating are even, comfortable warmth, no radiators on the walls, and, for wet systems, lower running temperatures that suit condensing boilers and heat pumps. The main disadvantages are the disruption and cost of fitting it, slower warm-up than radiators, higher running costs for electric systems, and limits on floor coverings, so it works best in new builds, extensions and rooms where the floor is coming up anyway.
In short
- Underfloor heating gives gentle, even heat across the room with no cold spots and no radiators.
- Wet systems run on water from a boiler or heat pump and are cheaper to run. Electric mats are cheaper to fit but cost more to run.
- It responds slowly, especially in a screed floor, so it suits steady heating rather than quick bursts.
- Tiles and stone work best. Thick carpet and underlay slow it down.
- It is easiest and best value in new floors: extensions, new builds and renovations.
How underfloor heating works
Underfloor heating turns the whole floor into a low temperature heat emitter. Because the heated surface is so large, it does not need to be very hot to warm the room.
There are two kinds:
- Wet (water) systems circulate warm water from your boiler or heat pump through plastic pipes laid in a screed, in grooved boards or between joists with metal spreader plates. A manifold with a pump and mixing valve controls the water to each room.
- Electric systems use heating cables or mats under the floor finish, controlled by a thermostat in each room.
Our underfloor heating installation team fits both, and the right one depends on the room, the floor and how you will use it.
The pros of underfloor heating
Even, comfortable heat
Radiators heat the air near them, which rises and circulates, so rooms can feel warm at head height and cool at your feet. Underfloor heating warms from the ground up, across the whole room. Most people find that more comfortable, and many find a room feels just as warm at a slightly lower thermostat setting.
No radiators on the walls
Without radiators you can place furniture, kitchen units and glazing wherever you like. That is a big part of why it is popular in open plan kitchens and extensions with large glazed doors.
Lower flow temperatures
A wet system needs far cooler water than radiators. The Energy Saving Trust points out that the large surface area lets underfloor heating run at lower temperatures, which is more efficient. A condensing boiler works most efficiently when the water coming back to it is cool, and a heat pump works much more efficiently at low flow temperatures. Underfloor heating suits both.
Quiet and low maintenance
Once it is in and balanced, a wet system has very little to go wrong in the floor itself. The pipes are normally laid as continuous loops with no joints under the floor, and the parts that do need attention (the pump, mixing valve and actuators) are at the manifold, where they can be reached.
Works well in bathrooms and kitchens
Tiled floors pass heat well, and a warm floor in a bathroom is a real comfort. It is easiest to add during a bathroom renovation, when the floor is up anyway.
The cons of underfloor heating
Installation cost and disruption
Fitting underfloor heating means taking up the floor. In a new build or extension that is not a problem. In an existing room it means lifting the floor finish, possibly raising the floor level, and relaying it. That is the biggest reason people decide against it.
Slow to warm up and cool down
A wet system in a screed floor heats a large mass of concrete before the room warms. It can take hours to heat from cold and holds its heat for a long time after it switches off. That is fine for steady heating on a sensible schedule, but it does not suit rooms you want warm quickly for an hour. Electric mats and low profile overlay systems respond faster.
Floor coverings are limited
Heat has to pass through whatever is on top. The Energy Saving Trust recommends carpet and underlay with a combined tog rating of 2.5 or lower, and warns that thick vinyl or laminate can slow heat transfer. Stone, ceramic tiles and engineered wood work best.
Electric systems cost more to run
Electricity usually costs more than gas for each unit of heat. Electric underfloor heating is best in smaller rooms used for shorter periods, such as a bathroom or cloakroom, rather than as the main heating for a whole house.
Harder to repair
If a cable or pipe is damaged under a finished floor, reaching it is disruptive. That makes installation quality and testing before the floor goes down very important.
It needs good insulation
Without insulation under the pipes or mats, a lot of the heat goes downwards into the structure. In an older house with an uninsulated floor, underfloor heating may not perform well unless the floor is insulated as part of the job.
Pros and cons at a glance
| Pros | Cons | |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | Even heat, warm floors, no cold spots | Slow to respond in screed floors |
| Space | No radiators, free walls | Floor may need raising |
| Running costs | Wet systems are efficient at low temperatures | Electric systems cost more to run |
| Installation | Straightforward in new floors | Disruptive in existing rooms |
| Floor finishes | Tiles and stone are ideal | Thick carpet and some vinyls slow it |
| Maintenance | Few parts, mostly at the manifold | Faults under the floor are hard to reach |
Where underfloor heating works best
- Extensions and new builds, where the floor is being built from scratch and insulation can go in underneath.
- Open plan kitchen and living spaces, where wall space is precious.
- Ground floors with a concrete slab, because the screed spreads heat well.
- Bathrooms and cloakrooms, particularly with electric mats under new tiles.
- Homes with a heat pump or planning one, because low flow temperatures make both work well.
The Energy Saving Trust notes that installers sometimes suggest underfloor heating downstairs with radiators upstairs, which is a sensible compromise in many homes.
Where it may not be the right choice
- Rooms with thick carpet you want to keep.
- Rooms you heat only occasionally and want warm quickly.
- Older houses with uninsulated suspended floors, unless you are prepared to insulate them.
- Upstairs rooms where the floor level cannot rise. Low profile systems help, but there are limits.
Can underfloor heating run from my boiler?
Yes. Any modern gas boiler, including a combi, can run a wet underfloor system through a manifold with its own pump and mixing valve. Radiators and underfloor heating can run from the same boiler, with the manifold blending the water down for the floor, and we often plan the two together as part of a central heating installation. The boiler needs to be large enough for the whole heat load. If your boiler is old and inefficient, it may be worth looking at a new boiler installation at the same time.
Mistakes to avoid
- Skipping insulation. Heat goes down as well as up.
- Choosing floor finishes after the heating is designed. The design depends on the finish.
- Expecting instant heat from a screed floor. Set the timer to suit it, or choose a faster system.
- Treating electric mats as whole-house heating. They are best in small rooms.
- Not testing before covering. Pipes should be pressure tested and cables tested before the floor goes down.
How we price it
Installations are quoted as a fixed price after a free survey, so the price you agree is the price you pay. The survey looks at your floors, the heat each room needs and your boiler, then recommends the right system. Our published rates for smaller heating work are on our prices page. Our work carries a 12 month labour guarantee, and bathrooms we install carry a 12 month guarantee.
Frequently asked questions
Is underfloor heating cheaper to run than radiators?
A well designed wet system can be, because it runs at lower water temperatures, which lets a condensing boiler or heat pump work more efficiently. Electric underfloor heating usually costs more to run than gas radiators.
How long does underfloor heating take to warm up?
It depends on the floor. A wet system in a thick screed can take a few hours from cold, while electric mats under tiles and low profile overlay systems warm up much faster. Most people run screed systems on a steady schedule rather than switching them on and off.
Can you put underfloor heating in an existing house?
Yes. Low profile overlay systems and electric mats are designed for existing floors, and wet pipes can go between joists on suspended timber floors. It is easiest when a room is being renovated anyway.
Does underfloor heating work with carpet?
It can, if the carpet and underlay together have a low tog rating. The Energy Saving Trust recommends a combined rating of 2.5 tog or lower.
Is underfloor heating worth it?
In extensions, new builds, open plan spaces and bathrooms, usually yes. In a room you do not plan to renovate, or one you heat only occasionally, radiators are usually simpler and better value.
Underfloor heating across Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and Cambridgeshire
If you are weighing up underfloor heating for an extension, kitchen or bathroom, our own engineers can survey the space, check your boiler and give you a fixed price. We are based in Stevenage, rated 4.9 on Google, and our phone is answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. See our underfloor heating installation page or call 01462 506374.
What our customers say
Speak to a local engineer
Vantage Plumbing and Heating covers Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and the surrounding areas. Call and talk to an engineer, or send us the details and we will come back to you with a price.
Gas Safe registered, number 956889. Emergency line answered 24/7.
Boiler engineers near you
Boiler playing up? Book a local Gas Safe engineer
We cover Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and Cambridgeshire. Choose your town:
Not listed? See all the areas we cover or call 01462 506 374